Latest Message - British Expat Messages

Post
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • Mark post as unread
  • Kay 
  • Site Admin 
  • Upload Users Avatar 
  • Joined: 22 Jan 2003 
  • Posts: 20619 
  • Location: Mostly South East Asia 
  • Karma What?
We're planning to expand the website with a book reviews section. To start with Dave and I will be reviewing expat related books. If anyone wants a little writing project please feel free to contribute your book reviews here. Any subject is welcome fiction, non-fiction, anything of interest. We'll publish the best ones on the main site.

Get writing!
CanDoCanGo - Promoting accessible travel for everyone

Are you selling up to move abroad? Why not visit HouseWiz for everything about buying, selling, or running a home?

You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality Visit poster's website Back to top
Post
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • Mark post as unread
  • JayneR 
  •  
  • Subscribe to BE Today 
  • Joined: 10 Apr 2005 
  • Posts: 974 
  • Location: Santo Tirso - northern Portugal 
  • Karma What?
I’ve been watching this thread and as no-one seems to want to be the first, I thought I’d do it. Kay you mentioned something about reviewing expat books. Quite a few years ago (about 15 I think!) I read an excellent book called “A Year in Provence” which was very popular at the time. I had a copy which I can’t find, probably lent it to someone and didn’t get it back, and I can’t remember who wrote it. It’s written by a Brit who gives up his job and sells everything to go and live in Provence in an old house which he and his wife spend a year renovating. It’s a very funny blog about the situations they get into, discoveries they make along the way and people they meet and how they deal with the influx of unwanted visitors looking for a cheap holiday in France!

OK, this is my offering. It’s a non-fiction which deals with what’s become quite a controversial subject.

1421 (The Year China Discovered the World) by Gavin Menzies.

The author is a retired Royal Navy Submarine Commanding Officer who was born in China in 1937 and where he spent the first two years of his life. He’s well equipped to have written this book having sailed the world in the wake of Columbus, Dias, Cabral and Vasco de Gama, Magellan and Captain Cook. When he retired he seriously took up what had always been a hobby, namely medieval history and in particular the maps and charts of early explorers.

His story started when he stumbled upon an incredible discovery, a clue hidden in an ancient map which suggested that the history of the world as it has been known and handed down for centuries would have to radically revised. After fifteen years of research, he finally wrote this book putting forward his theories and evidence that the famous “discoverers” were only using maps already drawn up by the Chinese a good few years before them.

“On 8 March 1421, the largest fleet the world had ever seen set sail from China. The ships, some nearly five hundred feet long, were under the command of Emperor Zhu Di’s loyal eunuch admirals. Their orders were “to proceed all the way to the end of the earth”.”

During this epic voyage, various ships and their crews had to be abandoned along the way for various reasons, in theory to be picked up again at a later date. This never happened for reasons explained in the book and Gavin Menzies uses persuasive evidence to support his theories – ancient maps, precise navigational knowledge, astronomy, surviving accounts of Chinese explorers and later European navigators as well as the traces the fleet left behind. (Edit - For example, some of the evidence showing links between the Incas and China - (Apart from DNA reports showing links) "Peru" is a Chinese name, villagers of Eten and Monsefu understood Chinese until a century ago, nearly 100 Peruvian villages have Chinese names, first British colonists saw wild elephants on the Ecuador/Colombia border, Friar Antonio de la Calancha found pictures of Chinese cavalry, Chinese body found emtombed at Trujllo, Peru shown on maps before Europeans arrived there, Chinese chickens found the length of Peru, coconuts and bananas (indigenous to SE Asia) found by first Europeans, Inca pottery with Chinese calligraphy, folklore links to Chinese folklore and divination ceremonies)

Since his book was published in 2002, and recently revised to include new findings, his theories are being taken ever more seriously but will we have the courage to admit he’s right at the cost of demoting our great explorers to the lesser ranks?

(Edit)
Weighing in at a mere 629 pages (including Appendixes and Notes), I personally got bored about half way through which frustrated me no-end. I felt like I was missing out on the fascinating stuff included in the rest of the book but as a curious onlooker, I just couldn't muster up the necessary strength to carry on! Gavin Menzies had already convinced me of his theory well before the half-way mark so I found the continuous show of proofs, etc., rather tedious. I'm sure he would have been capable of proving his point to a non-academic audience in half the number of pages. There are quite a lot of very nice photos and diagrams and reproductions of ancient maps which are fascinating. He's included quite a lot of technical stuff about astronomy, navigating, eclipses, DNA, etc. Perhaps if I had a more serious interest in the subject, I'd have been able to finish the book.

I'd recommend the book to anyone who's interested in ancient sea travel and exploration. There's also quite a lot of interesting historical info about China and the way of life at the time. Not light reading but extremely interesting and it's not an expensive book so even if you don't manage to get through the whole book, I think it's worth having just to be able to refer back to when (if) necessary.

www.1421.tv

See ya! Very Happy
Visit Not Delia for recipes, food news and reviews.
Last edited by JayneR on Sun 10 Jul 2005 17:12 GMT; edited 1 time in total
You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality Back to top
Post
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • Mark post as unread
  • Kay 
  • Site Admin 
  • Upload Users Avatar 
  • Joined: 22 Jan 2003 
  • Posts: 20619 
  • Location: Mostly South East Asia 
  • Karma What?
Thanks, Jayne. It's not easy to go first...

I enjoyed reading what you wrote but it left me with a few questions. What did you think of the book? Did you enjoy it? What did you like or dislike about it. Was it convincing? Would you recommend it? If so, to whom? Was it very readable or a bit scholarly?

The subject sounds fascinating but you've not made me feel as if I want to rush out and get it.

Hope this helps - the last thing I want to do is to discourage you.
CanDoCanGo - Promoting accessible travel for everyone

Are you selling up to move abroad? Why not visit HouseWiz for everything about buying, selling, or running a home?

You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality Visit poster's website Back to top
Post
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • Mark post as unread
  • JayneR 
  •  
  • Subscribe to BE Today 
  • Joined: 10 Apr 2005 
  • Posts: 974 
  • Location: Santo Tirso - northern Portugal 
  • Karma What?
Cheers, Kay. I've never reviewed a book before so those are good pointers. I'll get round to it later as it will probably take a bit of thinking about. It's a very thick book. I'll edit the original post instead of adding another post after this one.

See ya! Very Happy
Visit Not Delia for recipes, food news and reviews.
You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality Back to top
Post
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • Mark post as unread
  • Kay 
  • Site Admin 
  • Upload Users Avatar 
  • Joined: 22 Jan 2003 
  • Posts: 20619 
  • Location: Mostly South East Asia 
  • Karma What?
Excellent edit, and a great review, Jayne. Sorry I took so long to find it but edits don't show up as unread posts so it was a case of my having to remember to revisit.

Your discussion of the technical detail in the book reminded me of Master And Commander. I'd seen the film which starred Russell Crowe, and enjoyed it enough to buy the book. For me there was far too much detail about naval history in the book. Fine for those with an interest but too much for the casual reader.

Thanks again for your review. Hope you do some more...

Kay
CanDoCanGo - Promoting accessible travel for everyone

Are you selling up to move abroad? Why not visit HouseWiz for everything about buying, selling, or running a home?

You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality Visit poster's website Back to top
Post
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • Mark post as unread
  • quine 
  •  
  • Subscribe to BE Today 
  • Joined: 30 Nov 2004 
  • Posts: 311 
  •  
  • Karma What?
One of the most inspiring books I have read recently is "The Tartan Pimpernel" the autobiography of Donald Caskie. He was the minister at the Scots Kirk in Paris at the time of the German invasion in 1940. In spite of having several opportunities to leave he remained in France and helped to establish a network of escape routes and safe houses for Allied sevicemen trapped in wartorn Europe.
He tells the story in his own words and does not claim to be a hero but simply somebody who wanted to help his fellowman in the grim face of German aggression.
At all times his life was in danger but he never gave a thought for his own safety. This is a truly remarkable story of selfless devotion.
If you're going to buy or book online please help this site by using our affiliate links.
You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality Back to top
Post
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • Mark post as unread
  • JayneR 
  •  
  • Subscribe to BE Today 
  • Joined: 10 Apr 2005 
  • Posts: 974 
  • Location: Santo Tirso - northern Portugal 
  • Karma What?
There's nothing I enjoy more than a "good" story and your book sounds like a good story! Must keep my eyes open for that, or better still order it at FNAC, it'll probably be impossible to find here in Portugal, especially in English! Rolling Eyes

See ya! Very Happy
Subscribe to British Expat today to get the most out of our great community.
You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality Back to top
Post
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • Mark post as unread
  • winniewen1102 
  •  
  • Subscribe to BE Today 
  • Joined: 23 Jul 2005 
  • Posts: 23 
  •  
  • Karma What?
"I am after pleasure, not nutritional confirmation. But should you be concerned about such matters as fat intake, you should know that deep-frying is a relatively innocent occupation."
The above paragraph is from an article named "Fish and Chips", which is from a book named THE: BRIGHTONBOOK. (I am not shouting, that's what it is on the cover with a red "THE" and bold "BRIGHTON")
Someday in June, I woke up in the morning and got an email from a friend, who once stayed in Brighton for about 10 months. There were only a link to the introduction of this book and a brief line "I will be very happy if you can get this book for me." I always trust his taste and did get one at once.
You can hardly define a book like this. In addition to the lovely "fish and chips" article with a very personal-experienced recipe (3 and half pages), you can find poems and fictions written for or in Brighton;Comic strips and cartoons both colorful and B&W, and I like the postcards from the Seafront photographs so much... I then replied to my friend, "yes I have got the book, but since there is only one, I have decided to keep it to myself."
Highly recommended to those who enjoy bed-time reading, who like Brighton, and/or who enjoy creative things.

http://www.brighton-festival.org.uk/BrightonBook.asp
Shuang
Read the British Newspapers online!
You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality Back to top
Post
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • Mark post as unread
  • JayneR 
  •  
  • Subscribe to BE Today 
  • Joined: 10 Apr 2005 
  • Posts: 974 
  • Location: Santo Tirso - northern Portugal 
  • Karma What?
Hi Shuang,

Thanks so much for this recommendation. My cousin who lives in Geneva is originally from Brighton and I know she'll just love this book. I'm going to try to get it for her and send it as a surprise.

Thanks. See ya! Very Happy
Need Currency Exchange services? We've got it sussed.
You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality Back to top
Post
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • Mark post as unread
  • winniewen1102 
  •  
  • Subscribe to BE Today 
  • Joined: 23 Jul 2005 
  • Posts: 23 
  •  
  • Karma What?
JayneR wrote: I know she'll just love this book. I'm going to try to get it for her and send it as a surprise. Very Happy


Razz I am glad that it can be of help. and btw, I like surprise too, my address is... hahaha Laughing
Also I like the book 1421 you recommended as well.
Visit Not Delia for recipes, food news and reviews.
You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality Back to top
Post
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • Mark post as unread
  • JayneR 
  •  
  • Subscribe to BE Today 
  • Joined: 10 Apr 2005 
  • Posts: 974 
  • Location: Santo Tirso - northern Portugal 
  • Karma What?
Hi again,

Have you read "1421"? If you have, I'd love to hear your comments. From your name, I assume you're from that part of the world, or perhaps your family is.

See ya! Very Happy
Want to PM someone? You'll need to Subscribe to British Expat.
You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality Back to top
Post
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • Mark post as unread
  • winniewen1102 
  •  
  • Subscribe to BE Today 
  • Joined: 23 Jul 2005 
  • Posts: 23 
  •  
  • Karma What?
Hi ya,

Just like Garcia Marquez's "100 years of solitude", 1421 is another book that I kept starting and stopping--it's too heavy for me to plough to the end! But what you've assumed is right, I am from China and the author's exploration and narrative about the connections between Ancient China and the world are the main interesting part for me. So maybe it's reasonable to just skip-read it like I did and enjoy the interesting facts listed and proved in it. A lazy way, isn't it? Wink

Shuang
Worried about Insuring your home abroad? We have the answer.
You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality Back to top
Post
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • Mark post as unread
  • JayneR 
  •  
  • Subscribe to BE Today 
  • Joined: 10 Apr 2005 
  • Posts: 974 
  • Location: Santo Tirso - northern Portugal 
  • Karma What?
Hi again,

Lazy? Not at all, that's basically what I did after the first couple of hundred pages! The author didn't leave us much choice so I don't think we should beat ourselves up about it! Laughing I really found it fascinating and think that as time goes on we'll have to rethink a lot of "proven" history as new facts come to light (such as this story) and perhaps old prejudices wane. I wonder if this book would have found a publisher forty years ago (or perhaps even less). I doubt it.

Quote:Garcia Marquez's "100 years of solitude"


I don't know that book. Perhaps this is a silly question but what's it about?

Have you read "Wild Swans (The Daughters of China)" by Jung Chang? I cried through most of it, in fact I eventually stopped reading it. It was too heart-rending. I must pick it up again and try to finish it. Most of the story was indelibly engrained in my mind so I'll be able to just pick up where I left off.

For anyone who doesn't know the book. It's the true story of the author who was born and raised in China but not just her story. It's a family memoir and real-life saga of a Chinese family over three generations. Weighing in at 676 pages, she could not have told the story in less, each page as fascinating as the last, you'll need a strong head and stomach to be able to finish it.

See ya! Very Happy
Is your UK home unoccupied? Intasure can help.
You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality Back to top
Post
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • Mark post as unread
  • winniewen1102 
  •  
  • Subscribe to BE Today 
  • Joined: 23 Jul 2005 
  • Posts: 23 
  •  
  • Karma What?
http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/0060929790/103-7032647-9108630?v=glance
the noble-winner author wrote this hard-reading book, which has been wildly hailed, well but me.
And I was really about to talk about Jung Chang's another book "Mao: unknown story"! Very Happy To be honest, there are totally different comments to this book about the Chinese idolised Leader between foreigners and the Chinese. I have got the book but haven't really started yet. Eager to know some comments from people not working for Guardian or BBC.
Is your UK home unoccupied? Intasure can help.
You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality Back to top
Post
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality
  • Mark post as unread
  • JayneR 
  •  
  • Subscribe to BE Today 
  • Joined: 10 Apr 2005 
  • Posts: 974 
  • Location: Santo Tirso - northern Portugal 
  • Karma What?
Hi Shuang,

Were you thinking along these lines for example?

http://publicenemy1.blog-city.com/jung_changs_mao_the_unknown_story_post_i.htm

After reading some of the above critics, I probably won't bother because there seems to be some criticism of the lack of research/references to research to back it up. Interesting comments though. I like the reference to "Fear of a White Planet", appeals to my inner sense of humour. I have a detached way of looking at the world and am an island unto myself most of the time! Wink

See ya! Very Happy
Subscribe to British Expat today to get the most out of our great community.
You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality You will need to login, register or even subscribe to enable this functionality Back to top
Display posts from previous:   
  •  
British Food
  • All information, postings etc are copyright of British Expat Ltd © 2000-2013 or of the original author, and may not be reproduced elsewhere without written permission of the copyright holder.